| Consi Pigtail |
| Ben Randolph Benedictine College | DEC 9-3 | Gabriel Garcia Angeles Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Terrance Wise Bethany College | DEC 8-6 | Tanner Charles Missouri Valley College |
| Colton Orlando Lindenwood University | PIN | Keygan Foster Maryville University |
| Shai Lariviere Missouri Valley College | DEC 7-5 | Dakota Napoli Missouri Valley College |
| Clifford Ikenberry Benedictine College | DEC 11-10 | Jesse Martinelli Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Leo Hardy Lindsey Wilson College | DEFAULT | Alex Jones Lincoln College |
| Aaron Hane | PIN | Juan Arroyave Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Colt Rogers Bethany College | PIN | Robert Hall University of the Cumberlands |
| Deranta McCloud McKendree University | DEC 8-1 | James Lohman Bethany College |
| Kevin Steeby Benedictine College | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Harry Jacobsen Hannibal-LaGrange University |
| Brenden Murphy McKendree University | PIN | Cooper Powell Lindenwood-Belleville |
