| Raymond Borja NAVY | 8-4 | Chad Strube Unattached |
| Matthew Cimato Unattached | 2-0 | Alex Cisneros Unattached |
| Tyler Bedelyon CLAR |
| 8-4 |
| Blake Kastl Unattached |
| Ben Hunter NAVY | 7-1 | Brad Mutchnik Unattached |
| Jordan Michelson PENN | 9-4 | Ian Squires MD |
| Peter Ferrara Unattached | 9-4 | Josh Clark ODU |
| Trey Duncan NAVY | 6-1 | Peter Ishiguro Boston University |
| Alexander Richardson ODU | 5-4 | Blake Roulo BUFF |
| Christian Barber UNC | PIN 5:57 | Zachary Ross Unattached |
| Derek Golner UNC | 15-0 | Tyler Newton Unattached |
| Brennan Brumley ODU | PIN 0:59 | Javier Rodriguez ARMY |
| Seth Beitz PSU | 14-4 | Daniel Luty CAMP |
| James English PSU | 8-2 | Dillon Gavlock Unattached |
| Augustus Sako Unattached | 10-3 | Brooks Martino PENN |
| Cole Moseley Unattached | 7-0 | Thomas Lebarre CAMP |
| Devin Cook Unattached | 6-5 | Alfred Murabito PENN |
| Connor Melde Army Prep | PIN | Brett Benedict ARMY |
| Michael Steplen LEH | PIN 2:43 | Michael Bennett WVU |
| Raymond Borja NAVY | 9-4 | Lou Mascola MD |
| Matthew Cimato Unattached | 8-2 | John Evashevski Unattached |
| Joey Kielbasa Unattached | 6-0 | Jacob Kingett Unattached |
| Jahlani Callender Unattached | 5-3 | Domenic Pietropaolo Unattached |
| Colin Saunders Boston University | 7-3 | Gabe LaVey NCST |
| Chad Strube Unattached | 7-3 | David Owens PSU |
| Andrew Alton PSU | PIN 5:34 | Albert Woody LEH |