| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | PIN | Trevor Jauch MIZZ |
| Nick Adams UNCO | DEC 11-5 | William Johnson APP |
| Tanner Hough DUKE | FORFEIT | Nicholas Hucke MIZZ |
| Carter McElhany AF | DEC 3-2 | Dan King Cleveland State University |
| Brent Jorge CAMP | PIN | Nick Flannery Cleveland State University |
| Eric Wilson MIZZ | DEC 4-3 | Joe Locksmith NAVY |
| Matt Nelson UVA | DEC 5-1 | Matthew Kraus ASU |
| Jimmy Nehls UVA | DEC 9-6 | Kyle Casaletto Unattached |