| Round of 32 | ||
| Brian Thompson UNCP | DEC 3-2 | Dylan Greene Newberry College |
| Evan Henderson UNC | PIN | Tyler Ross UNCP |
| Cory Wagner CAMP | PIN | JJ Johnson Newberry College |
| Sam Speno NCST | MAJ DEC 17-7 | Jacob Kingett ODU |
| Daniel Ownbey UNCP | TF 20-5 | Edward Stokes Coker College |
| Justin Van Hoose UVA | PIN | Ferdinand Goke UNCP |
| Patrick Hutton NCST | FORFEIT | Gerald Ronnau VT |
| Nick Young Newberry College | FORFEIT | George Weber GWU |
| Jake Velarde ODU | DEC 7-1 | Joe Fought Coker College |
| Chris Mecate ODU | TF 17-0 | Hunter Hefner Wolfpack Wrestling Club |
| Jon Stillo Centenary University (New Jersey) | DEC 8-6 | James McCord DAV |
| Rashad Cunnigham Coker College | PIN | Lucas Setzer UNCP |
| Shane Arechiga MD | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Alexander Palinski DAV |
| Sahid Kargbo GMU | DEC 13-11 | Michael Dahlstrom CAMP |
| Jake DeAngelo NCST | DEC 7-0 | Ryan Blackwell UNCP |
| Joey Moon UNC | DEC 4-0 | Jordan Tolbert CAMP |