| Round of 32 | ||
| Max Rohskopf NCST | PIN | Chris Williams CAMP |
| Kevin Birmingham DAV | PIN | Collin Munson CAMP |
| Brent Jorge CAMP | DEC 3-1 | Randy Shine NCST |
| Robert Janis MD | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Eric Milks UNCP |
| Cameron Bowen NRV Mat club | DEC 7-4 | Sean Faro UNCP |
| Christian Barber UNC | DEC 8-5 | Jake Faust DUKE |
| Brian Hamann NCST | PIN | Reggie Allen UNCP |
| Cohl Fulk NCST | DEC 3-2 | Chris Yankowich UVA |
| Luis Camacho UNCP | MAJ DEC 15-3 | Mattheos Lozier NRV Mat club |
| Kevin Johnson Jr ODU | DEC 2-1 | Cole Moseley AU |
| Seiji Borja Newberry College | PIN | Brad Mutchnik AU |
| Beau Donahue NCST | DEC 6-5 | Austin Eads ODU |
| Justin Pencook UNCP | TF 17-0 | Codi Rothermel Newberry College |
| Alexander Richardson ODU | PIN | Kevin Thompson Coker College |
| Jesse Holton MD | FORFEIT | Chad Hoff UNCP |
| TJ Miller UVA | DEC 8-5 | Nick Heilmann UNC |