| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Adam Nickleson PITT-J | PIN | Dusty Floyd UVA |
| Alex DeCiantis DREX | FORFEIT | Philip Robilotto Unattached |
| Jason Grimes AU | DEC 7-0 | Robert Hankins NYU |
| James Corbett BRWN | PIN | Matt Zippilli York College (Pa.) |
| Giovanni Ortiz Kutztown University | PIN | Nathan Dow ARMY |
| Brett Dempsey AU | DEC 3-0 | Adam Schroeder FM |
| Patrick Sheehan NYU | DEC 7-2 | Dylan Dailey PSU |
| Travis McKillop PITT-J | PIN | Brandon Vorrius BRWN |