| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi Pigtail | ||
| Derek Geiges OKLA | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Matthew Gancayco PRIN |
| Craemer Hedash ARMY | PIN | George Baker York College (Pa.) |
| Zach Wilson ODU | DEC 10-4 | Brian McCrystal Coe College |
| John Belanger ARMY | FORFEIT | Shane Connolly |
| Matt Hammerstone BLOOM | DEC 9-4 | Caleb Livingston PSU |
| Matthew Fisher SHU | DEC 10-6 | Billy Ramsey LEH |
| Shane Fenningham DREX | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Josh Ellis PRIN |
| Matt Eulau NYU | DEC 15-9 | Ryan O'Connor DREX |
| Sam Molina PITT-J | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Tyler Miller Messiah University |
| L.J. Remillard BRWN | TF 15-0 | Will Korzeniewski Messiah University |
| Josh Toal Messiah University | PIN | Dylan Lojac NYU |
| Zac Wawrzyniak-Bush MVILLE | DEC 6-4 | Dustin Fuller NAVY |
| Cristian Masaya AU | DEC 3-0 | Ben Wise Messiah University |
| Austin Rose DREX | DEC 5-3 | Brenan McAllister BUCK |