| Finals |
| Nestor Taffur Unattached1st | 6-3 | Craig Eifert Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Ryan Preisch Unattached3rd | 7-4 | Coleman Gracey ARMY4th |
| Consi Semi |
| Garett Hammond Unattached | 15-2 | Kyle Bova Unattached |
| Coleman Gracey ARMY | PIN 4:34 | Jordan Pagano Unattached |
| David Bergida VT | 10-0 | Anthony DePrez Unattached |
| Nick Visicaro Unattached | 3-2 | Mikey Simmons Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Craig Eifert Unattached | 8-7 | Ryan Preisch Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Kyle Bova Unattached | 3-1 | Zach Heeter Unattached |
| Jordan Pagano Unattached | 4-2 | Donovan Peek ARMY |
| Anthony DePrez Unattached | 6-1 | Dillon Gavlock Unattached |
| Mikey Simmons Unattached | 6-2 | Inan Sikel Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Donovan Peek ARMY | 12-3 | William Sullivan LEH |
| Jordan Pagano Unattached | 12-10 | Patrick Davis Unattached |
| Anthony DePrez Unattached | PIN 2:00 | Franklin And Marshall |
| Dillon Gavlock Unattached | 8-4 | Ty Schoffstall Unattached |
| Mikey Simmons Unattached | PIN 1:25 | Caleb Livingston PSU |
| Quarterfinal |
| Ryan Preisch Unattached | 6-2 | Coleman Gracey ARMY |
| Craig Eifert Unattached | 9-7 | Garett Hammond Unattached |
| Nestor Taffur Unattached | 14-4 | David Bergida VT |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Patrick Davis Unattached | PIN | Jonathan Feaster Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Ryan Preisch Unattached | 6-0 | Mikey Simmons Unattached |
| Coleman Gracey ARMY | PIN | Andrew Reca RIDER |
| Garett Hammond Unattached | 14-6 | Dillon Gavlock Unattached |
| Craig Eifert Unattached | PIN | Tony King Unattached |
| Nick Visicaro Unattached | PIN 4:13 | Jordan Pagano Unattached |
| David Bergida VT | 4-0 | Kyle Bova Unattached |
| Nestor Taffur Unattached | PIN 0:56 | Troy Taylor ARMY |
| Round of 32 |
| Mikey Simmons Unattached | 2-1 | Zach Heeter Unattached |
| Andrew Reca RIDER | 7-2 | Anthony Lombardo Unattached |
| Garett Hammond Unattached | 18-2 | William Sullivan LEH |
| Tony King Unattached | 6-2 | Jonathan Feaster Unattached |
| Craig Eifert Unattached | 13-1 | Patrick Davis Unattached |
| Jordan Pagano Unattached | PIN 6:39 | Anthony DePrez Unattached |
| Nick Visicaro Unattached | 9-5 | Jacob Conners FM |
| Kyle Bova Unattached | PIN | Joe Guzzo Middlesex Community College |
| David Bergida VT | 5-2 | Inan Sikel Unattached |
