| Consi 16 #2 |
| Quamaine Thomas SUNY-Oswego | FORFEIT | Jesse Meaney Long Island University |
| Chris Wymer Ithaca College | DEC 5-3 | Tyler Edwards Ithaca College |
| Nicholas Heck Oneonta State | DEC 9-7 | Kyle Mulcahy Jamestown Community College |
| Nate Henkle US Merchant Marine Academy | DEC 4-3 | James Punzone SUNY-Oswego |
| Casey Jones SUNY Brockport | DEC 12-7 | Sam Cullen SUNY-Oswego |
| Jake Sepor Rochester Institute of Technology | DEC 6-1 | Isaac Hammonds US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Dylan Caruana BING | PIN | Bryan Mongiello SUNY Brockport |
| Nathan Palmer SUNY Brockport | PIN | Marc Gonzales SUNY-Cortland |
| Tom Nevilizer Niagara County Community College | TF 16-0 | Michael Crespo Stony Brook Wrestling Club |
| Joe Moita COLU | MAJ DEC 16-6 | Jonathan Ptacek SUNY-Oswego |
| Rocco Russo BUFF | PIN | Jack Lucie ARMY |
| Ryan Dunphy Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | DEC 3-2 | Chris Fantauzzo SUNY-Cortland |
