| Round of 16 |
| Sam Schwartzapfel Nassau Community College | DEC 6-5 | Mike Beckwith SUNY-Cortland |
| John Messinger NYU | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Duely Espinal Nassau Community College |
| Zack Zupan BING | PIN | Mike Southwick Jamestown Community College |
| Bobby Fehr HOF | TF 16-0 | Troy Taylor ARMY |
| Nick Terdick HOF | PIN | Ryan Therrien BUFF |
| Jesse Shanaman COR | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Jesse Bader Hunter College |
| Chandler Smith ARMY | PIN | Tyrel White COLU |
| Chad Ryan COLU | PIN | Geoffrey Bilder US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Zach Colgan Niagara County Community College | DEC 6-3 | Samuel Rachman Oneonta State |
| Nick Velez Ithaca College | TF 19-3 | Corey Ashe Long Island University |
| Matt Russo COR | DEC 7-4 | Ryan Marriott Alfred State College |
| Donovan Peek ARMY | DEC 5-2 | Codie Nichols Alfred State College |
| Coleman Gracey ARMY | TF 17-0 | Mitchell Fisher Oneonta State |
| Anthony Lombardo BING | PIN | Shaun Holliday Stony Brook Wrestling Club |
| Konnor Kremer Alfred State College | DEC 4-0 | Moses Sun USMA Prep School |
| Anthony DePrez BING | PIN | Coty Lutz Rochester Institute of Technology |
