| Round of 16 |
| Patrick Sheehan NYU | DEC 5-0 | Jake Horton Long Island University |
| Austin Wilding ARMY | TF 16-0 | Ronnie King Long Island University |
| Tony Lock BUFF | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Vincent Provenzano Oneonta State |
| Jeff Palmeri SUNY Brockport | DEC 7-2 | Miguel Ponce Hunter College |
| Scott Bova SUNY-Oswego | DEC 5-0 | Ryan Richter Jamestown Community College |
| Samson Imonode ARMY | PIN | Nick Fisk Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Tyler Beckwith SUNY-Cortland | DEC 2-1 | Steven Sabella Ithaca College |
| Gabe Dean COR | TF 25-10 | Cory Damiana HOF |
| Brett Perry BUFF | DEC 4-3 | Chris Loew COLU |
| Daniel Viera US Merchant Marine Academy | DEFAULT | Kris Schimak Unattached |
| Scott Votino ARMY | DEC 5-1 | Gavin Berkley USMA Prep School |
| Gio Santiago Nassau Community College | TF 21-3 | Clinton Boone Farmingdale State College |
| Austin Weigel BUFF | DEC 6-4 | Daniel Choi COR |
| Thomas Anania Ithaca College | PIN | John Zweier Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Billy George COR | PIN | Nick Burch US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Ty Walter Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | MAJ DEC 22-10 | Liam Korbul Ithaca College |
