| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 |
| William Jenkins WVU | MAJ DEC 22-10 | Jeff Held Lindenwood University |
| Neal Molloy UINDY | TF 18-3 | Dillon Scanlon Benedictine College |
| Derek Miller Grand View University | DEC 4-2 | Brandon Seward Graceland University |
| Louis Colonna WVU | MAJ DEC 17-4 | Trent Robb Bethany College |
| Tim O'Connor University of Central Oklahoma | TF 17-0 | Jonathan Arenas Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Sean Dulom Missouri Valley College | PIN | Coulter Allen Graceland University |
| Ty Millward WVU | DEC 6-0 | Austin Culton NIU |
| Greg Jacquez Lindenwood University | DEC 8-3 | Brant Schafer Davenport University |