| Round of 16 |
| Donald Donnelly COLU | DEC 9-4 | Montana Walton US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Joseph Fiore US Merchant Marine Academy | TF 17-0 | Mike Ricci SUNY Cortland Wrestling Club |
| Ryan Kromer BUFF | MAJ DEC 8-0 | McKenzie Callahan Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Frank Affronti HOF | DEC 2-0 | Blake Bunce US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Declan Gray Hunter College | PIN | Tracy Cistrunk Niagara County Community College |
| Brian Harvey ARMY | PIN | Jaison White Ithaca College |
| Alex Kelly Niagara County Community College | TF 22-4 | Gaaret Marinelli NYU |
| Graham Ratermann ARMY | DEC 3-1 | Jacob George COR |
| Zuriel Yi US Merchant Marine Academy | DEC 9-8 | Griffin Kent Niagara County Community College |
| Jermaine John HOF | PIN | Ryan Therrien BUFF |
| Brian Realbuto COR | PIN | Lantze Lange Oneonta State |
| Troy Seymour SUNY-Oswego | DEC 7-4 | Erk Adon Nassau Community College |
| Zack Hernandez COLU | PIN | Nicholas Brutus Hunter College |
| Andrew Garcia COR | DEC 1-0 | Milik Dawkins Finger Lakes Wrestling Club |
| Ben Harvey ARMY | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Jake Kocsis BING |
| Mike Southwick Jamestown Community College | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Dan Arkow Long Island University |
