| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Mike Hughes HOF | PIN | Santino Pelusi NYU |
| Trevor Smith ARMY | DEC 6-1 | Sam Weinger Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Branden Joest US Merchant Marine Academy | TF 17-1 | Kade Andrews SUNY-Oswego |
| Jake Gunning BUFF | PIN | Robert Cuomo SUNY Sullivan |
| Austin Buttry ARMY | DEC 7-3 | Ian James BUFF |
| Joseph Sprung Ithaca College | PIN | Kevin Dinh US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Jeramy Sweany COR | PIN | Dennis Melendez Hunter College |
| Cole Tristram Unattached | PIN | Adam Groesbeck Oneonta State |
| Monair McDonald Long Island University | PIN | Jackson Wilson NYU |
| Brock Cvijanovich BING | PIN | Kenneth Davenport Ithaca College |
| Dennis Atiyeh COR | PIN | Dequan Brooks Niagara County Community College |
| David Farr ARMY | PIN | Kelsey Patten Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Peter Strassfield ARMY | PIN | Francis Walter US Merchant Marine Academy |