| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| DJ Fehlman LHU | PIN | Alexander Root Unattached |
| Malachi Krenzelak PITT-J | PIN | Logan Wilson Unattached |
| Kevin Kinyua Unattached | TF 20-3 | Justin Smythe Unattached |
| Tanner Cahill PITT-J | PIN | Jalil Harris Mercyhurst University |
| Chris Eddins Unattached | DEC 4-0 | Owen Wherley Unattached |
| Chris Mullins Unattached | DEFAULT | Avery Henry Unattached |
| Noah Burkhart PITT-J | DEC 10-4 | Matthew Dowler Unattached |
| Tyler Vath Unattached | DEC 10-5 | Brian Friery Unattached |