| Round of 32 | ||
| Jared Walker Unattached | PIN | Dom Vitale Unattached |
| Jared Siegrist LHU | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Sam Colebert Mercyhurst University |
| Brandon Stokes Unattached | PIN | John Prentice Penn State DuBois |
| Donovan McAfee PITT | DEC 9-4 | Koltyn Eason Unattached |
| Ray Bethea UVA | MAJ DEC 15-4 | William Jenkins Unattached |
| Taylor Cahill CLAR | TF 15-0 | Kane Patron Mercyhurst University |
| Drew Hull UVA | TF 16-0 | Derek Ridgeway Mercyhurst University |
| Mitch Hartman BUCK | DEC 7-2 | Jack Peura Unattached |
| Austin Bell Unattached | TF 16-1 | Paul Zacherl Unattached |