| Round of 32 | ||
| Jerald Spohn Unattached | PIN | Joe Knarr Penn State DuBois |
| Corey Hazel LHU | DEC 9-6 | Nico Pecora PITT-J |
| Levi Niebauer PITT-J | TF 17-1 | Jack Walsh Unattached |
| Shane Mast KENT | PIN | Derrick Washington Unattached |
| Terrell Fields Unattached | DEC 5-3 | Deven Simpson Mercyhurst University |
| Scott Marmoll CLAR | DEC 4-3 | Devon Van Cura Unattached |
| Derek Dragon LHU | PIN | Deontay Wadley Penn State DuBois |
| Gregg Harvey Unattached | PIN | Adam Mackie LHU |