| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Nick Casella Nassau Community College | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Alex Salvaggio Niagara County Community College |
| Joe Russ BING | DEC 7-2 | Vincent Turano Long Island University |
| Sean Lyons NYU | PIN | Evan Corso SUNY-Oswego |
| Kyle Krasavage HOF | DEC 15-11 | Nick Noel ARMY |
| John Arceri Nassau Community College | DEC 8-4 | Anthony Messina Oneonta State |
| Jacob Nicholson BING | TF 17-2 | Christian Briody COLU |
| Will Koll COR | DEC 4-1 | Jacob Macalolooy COLU |
| Griffin Higginbotham COR | DEC 4-0 | Thomas Miers COLU |
| Nick Wahba Ithaca College | DEC 9-3 | Connor Burkert HOF |
| Trence Gillem COR | PIN | Max Kutsepau SUNY-Oswego |
| Evan Drill NYU | DEC 11-4 | Sean O'Hagan SUNY Brockport |
| Ryan Peters BUFF | DEC 8-1 | Ian McNitt COR |
| Noah Hanau ARMY | DEC 6-1 | Charlie Kane HOF |
| Max Pickett Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | DEC 9-6 | Christian Doyle ARMY |
| Chris Meloni Nassau Community College | PIN | Ahken Chu Oneonta State |
| Eli Bienstock COR | PIN | Chris Wymer Ithaca College |