| Round of 16 |
| Nate Rose BUFF | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Matt Doggett COLU |
| Triston Engle SUNY Brockport | MAJ DEC 16-4 | Jeremiah Imonode ARMY |
| Carlos Toribio Ithaca College | PIN | Peter Pjetri Oneonta State |
| Daniel Smith SUNY-Oswego | MAJ DEC 13-0 | Brenden Nunziata SUNY-Cortland |
| Benjamin Honis COR | TF 18-0 | Branden Joest US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Jack La Corte NYU | DEC 3-2 | Elijah Sampo Niagara County Community College |
| Jacob Anderson COR | PIN | Deny Travarez Nassau Community College |
| Gavin Berkley ARMY | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Tanner Nielsen Ithaca College |
| Joe Messare Rochester Institute of Technology | DEC 4-0 | Kevin Morgans SUNY-Cortland |
| Ben Darmstadt Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Liam Korbul Ithaca College |
| Freddy Vidal Long Island University | TF 16-0 | Steven Hoadley ARMY |
| Steve Congenie COR | MAJ DEC 17-5 | Jack Buell ARMY |
| Bennett Paulson ARMY | TF 19-0 | David Hernandez Niagara County Community College |
| Thomas Anania Ithaca College | TF 16-0 | Jake McKeown College of Mount Saint Vincent |
| Dalton Shoop ARMY | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Ryan Ford Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
