| Round of 32 |
| Raymond Jazikoff NYU | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Dakota Gardner Niagara County Community College |
| Jack Lucie ARMY | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Jackson Bell SUNY Brockport |
| Jaelen Jean Niagara County Community College | PIN | Patrick Carroll SUNY Ulster |
| William Heine Hunter College | DEC 7-3 | Troy Edwards NYU |
| Isaac McMillan ARMY | TF 17-1 | Karl Linneman SUNY Cortland Wrestling Club |
| Ricky Stamm HOF | DEC 7-0 | Howie Nolan Jamestown Community College |
| Derek Krajewski COR | PIN | Eric Petrie Oneonta State |
| Nathan Palmer SUNY Brockport | DEC 5-0 | Kyle Torre SUNY-Oswego |
| Beau Guffey ARMY | MAJ DEC 16-3 | Kyle Parella SUNY Cortland Wrestling Club |
| Laurence Kosoy COLU | PIN | Coty Lutz Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Rami Pellumbi COR | TF 21-2 | Dashea Edwards SUNY-Oswego |
| James Saylor ARMY | TF 16-0 | Matthew Mawby Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Francis Nassivera Ithaca College | PIN | Trevor Rittersback SUNY Brockport |
| Nicholas Heck Oneonta State | DEC 3-2 | Zack Bendick SUNY Brockport |
| Kyle Simaz COR | MAJ DEC 14-1 | Anthony Fano Ithaca College |
| Tyler Zimmer COLU | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Adam Santoro Finger Lakes Wrestling Club |
