| Cons. Round 2 |
| Jesse Rodgers Broncs Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Grant Turnmire Cleveland Wrestling Club |
| Mikey Racciato Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 8-7 | Patricio Lugo Edinboro Scotsman Wrestling |
| Timothy Rooney Golden Pride Wrestling Club | DEC 7-0 | Jake Keller Clarion Wrestling Club |
| Taleb Rahmani Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 9-8 | Beau Donahue Wolfpack Wrestling Club |
| Jake Short Minnesota Storm | DEC 5-0 | Danny Boychuck Terrapin Wrestling Club |
| Kevin Laubach Bloomsburg Wrestling | TF 14-4 | Robbie Mathers Sunkist Kids Wrestling Club |
| Kamaal Shakur Chattanooga RTC | TF 13-0 | Timmy Box Northern Colorado RTC |
| Ty Lydic Griffins Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Sean Miller VHW |
| Alexander Smythe Buffalo RTC | TF 10-0 | William Jenkins WVU |
| James Wolfe EMU | TF 14-0 | William Lewis App State RTC |
| Frankie Garcia Bearcat Wrestling Club | PIN | Danny Reed NYC RTC |
| Jim Devine Buffalo RTC | PIN | Zaal Zafari Edinboro Scotsman Wrestling |
| Tom Page AU | TF 11-1 | Brad Green Northern Illinois Elite |
| Tyler Smith Buffalo Valley RTC | DEC 8-5 | Erik Travers Southern Illinois Wrestling Cl |
| Brendon Corbert Bloomsburg Wrestling | DEC 8-6 | Angel Velasquez Northern Illinois Elite |
| Sam Speno Wolfpack Wrestling Club | DEC 11-8 | Tristan Rifanburg Bearcat Wrestling Club |
| Angel Najar App State RTC | TF 16-6 | Adam Habeil |
| Matt Leshinger NYC RTC | DEC 9-6 | Neal Molby Greyhound Wrestling Club |
| Chase Hack Warrior Elite Wrestling Club | PIN | Reginald Edwards MIZZ |
| Zac Hall Michigan Wrestling Club | DEC 7-6 | James Dekrone WVU |
| Karsten Van Velsor Southern Illinois Wrestling Cl | TF 16-6 | Joe Trovato Pittsburgh Wrestling Club |
| Elroy Perkin Blugold Wrestling | TF 23-12 | Frank Yatteni Grizzly Wrestling Club |
| Mitch Finesilver Blue Blood Wrestling Club | TF 12-1 | Jacob Macalolooy NYC RTC |
| Renaldo Rodriguez-Spencer ISU | TF 11-0 | Matt Gudenau MSU |
| Miller Clark App State RTC | DEC 4-1 | Shane Jones Virginia Beach RTC |
| Michael Longo App State RTC | DEC 12-9 | Jonathan Furnas COR |
| Nick Boggs Lake Erie College | TF 10-0 | James Berg Minnesota Storm |
| Austin Eads Virginia Beach RTC | DEC 12-8 | Matthew Raines Patriot Elite RTC |
| Josh Maruca Sunkist Kids Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Matthew Zovistoski App State RTC |
