| Andrew Gunning Unattached | PIN | Eric Hall Unattached |
| Brett Dempsey AU | PIN | Chris Anglin St. Andrews University |
| Ben Stone WIS | DEC 6-1 | Edwin Rubio Virginia-attached |
| Jake Scanlan Unattached | PIN | Zack Willard Unattached |
| Jacob Kasper DUKE | PIN | Jackson Price GWU |
| Ali Wahab Unattached | DEC 4-3 | Daniel Herman Unattached |
| Michael Johnson Unattached | MAJ DEC 15-5 | Zach Schrader Unattached |
| Mike Kosoy NCST | PIN | Robert Scherer Unattached |
| Michael Boykin NCST | MAJ DEC 17-6 | Will Cooley DAV |
| Boyce Cornwell GWU | PIN | Devin Washington St. Andrews University |