| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Brandon Miller Penn State Behrend | DEC 9-5 | Michael Resignalo Unattached |
| Evan Campbell BLOOM | DEC 8-7 | Josiah McClarren Unattached |
| Dallas Bulsak Unattached | PIN | Anthony Colello Unattached |
| Sean Agnella Unattached | DEC 5-4 | Mohamed Kaba Unattached |
| Joe Sliwoski CLAR | DEC 10-6 | Riley Barth PITT |
| Taylor Ortz CLAR | TF 16-0 | Justin Mason Unattached |
| Andrew Barnett Unattached | FORFEIT | Nick Monico Unattached |