| Round of 32 |
| Kieran Duggan US Merchant Marine Academy | PIN | Christian Savino NYU |
| Jon Walden ARMY | PIN | Troy Edwards NYU |
| Adam Santoro COR | PIN | Kyle Barnard SUNY-Oswego |
| Sam Schneider Ithaca College | PIN | Ryan Nichols Long Island University |
| T.J. Fabian Long Island University | PIN | Zack Brown SUNY Brockport |
| Austin Whitney Ithaca College | MAJ DEC 18-5 | Coty Lutz Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Alex Smythe BUFF | PIN | Ezekiel Thomas Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Isaac Mathews SUNY-Oswego | DEC 8-1 | Skyler Holt SUNY Brockport |
| Tanner Cook Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Ryan Sebesta Niagara County Community College |
| Kaidon Winters Rochester Institute of Technology | PIN | Howie Nolan Jamestown Community College |
| Samuel Cokeley Unattached | PIN | Charles Franchina US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Fredy Stroker Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | TF 16-0 | Jordan Kayes SUNY Brockport |
| Antonio LaRocca Nassau Community College | PIN | Michael LaRuffa Unattached |
| Raymond Jazikoff NYU | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Corey Farrell SUNY Brockport |
