| Consi 16 #2 |
| Dylan Shotwell Maryville University | DEC 11-9 | Ethan Schumaker McKendree University |
| Conner Villarmia Maryville University | MAJ DEC 14-6 | Bryan Simpson Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| John Lee Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 12-5 | Malik Nottage Ellsworth Community College |
| Tristan Kole Meador Williams Baptist College | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Cameron Ward Lindsey Wilson College |
| Ben Parkhurst Ouachita Baptist University | PIN | Justus Sheppard Lincoln College |
| Martell Boone MIZZ | DEC 6-4 | Alex Leone Iowa Central Community College |
| Dylan Shotwell Maryville University | PIN | Joshua Strauss Benedictine College |
| Tristan Kole Meador Williams Baptist College | DEC 7-0 | Daryus Webb Williams Baptist College |
| Kyle Caldwell Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College | FORFEIT | Jensen McDermott Benedictine College |
| Conner Villarmia Maryville University | TF 20-4 | Esai Gallegos Baker University |
| Caleb Norris Davenport University | PIN | Angelo Talbert Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| John Lee Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 7-5 | Christian Brinkley Labette Community College |
