| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Crossover | ||
| Gable Strickland LHU | DEC 2-1 | Satoshi Abe LEH |
| Dominic Carone ARMY | DEC 3-2 | Richard Treanor ARMY |
| Jake Giordano College of New Jersey | DEC 5-3 | Mason Myers PITT |
| Kelly Dunnigan PENN | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Bryce Cockrell Long Island University |
| Michael Colaiocco PENN | DEC 4-0 | Devan Turner ORST |
| Dillon Murphy HARV | DEC 5-4 | Ja'Kerion Merritt CMU |
| Lukas Richie PENN | DEC 9-6 | Matthew Morris MVILLE |
| Mark Montgomery ARMY | DEC 9-4 | Vincente Perez CMU |
| Malyke Hines | ||
| FORFEIT |
| Jason Shaner ORST |
| Michael Rapuano GMU | MAJ DEC 17-4 | Danny Capozzoli MVILLE |
| John Lafferty SHU | DEC 16-12 | Michael Tandurella VMI |
| Tommy Maddox BUFF | TF 19-1 | Thomas Volpe SHU |
| Round Robin 3 | ||
| Daniel Uhorchuk ARMY | DEC 3-1 | Jacob Gardner Gannon University |
| Thomas Huxtable Long Island University | PIN | Aseel Almudhala Gannon University |
| Gable Strickland LHU | TF 19-3 | Matthew Morris MVILLE |
| Satoshi Abe LEH | DEC 5-3 | Lukas Richie PENN |
| Michael Colaiocco PENN | DEFAULT | Jason Shaner ORST |
| Dajauhn Hertzog PITT | DEC 6-2 | Jett Pattison |
| Dominic Carone ARMY | PIN | Tommy Maddox BUFF |
| Jake Giordano College of New Jersey | DEC 6-3 | Michael Rapuano GMU |
| Byron Daubert PITT | PIN | Jake Carlucci SHU |
| Devan Turner ORST | DEC 4-3 | Malyke Hines LEH |
| Richard Treanor ARMY | TF 17-1 | Bryce Cockrell Long Island University |
| Danny Capozzoli MVILLE | PIN | John Lafferty SHU |
| Round Robin 2 | ||
| Dillon Murphy HARV | DEC 4-0 | Lukas Richie PENN |
| Dajauhn Hertzog PITT | PIN | Thomas Huxtable Long Island University |
| Jake Giordano College of New Jersey | DEC 5-3 | Michael Tandurella VMI |
| Jacob Gardner Gannon University | PIN | Jake Carlucci SHU |
| Byron Daubert PITT | DEC 10-4 | Daniel Uhorchuk ARMY |
| Aseel Almudhala Gannon University | MAJ DEC 19-7 | Jett Pattison |
| Michael Colaiocco PENN | TF 19-2 | Vincente Perez CMU |
| Dominic Carone ARMY | DEC 7-4 | Kelly Dunnigan PENN |
| Malyke Hines LEH | DEC 4-2 | Mark Montgomery ARMY |
| Bryce Cockrell Long Island University | TF 18-3 | Thomas Volpe SHU |
| Gable Strickland LHU | DEC 5-2 | Ja'Kerion Merritt CMU |
| Mason Myers PITT | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Danny Capozzoli MVILLE |
| Round Robin 1 | ||
| Michael Rapuano GMU | MAJ DEC 14-6 | Michael Tandurella VMI |
| Byron Daubert PITT | DEC 7-1 | Jacob Gardner Gannon University |
| Satoshi Abe LEH | DEC 3-2 | Dillon Murphy HARV |
| Jason Shaner ORST | MAJ DEC 15-6 | Vincente Perez CMU |
| Tommy Maddox BUFF | PIN | Kelly Dunnigan PENN |
| Jett Pattison | DEC 5-4 | Thomas Huxtable Long Island University |
| Daniel Uhorchuk ARMY | DEC 8-2 | Jake Carlucci SHU |
| Dajauhn Hertzog PITT | PIN | Aseel Almudhala Gannon University |
| Mason Myers PITT | TF 16-0 | John Lafferty SHU |
| Devan Turner ORST | DEC 4-3 | Mark Montgomery ARMY |
| Richard Treanor ARMY | PIN | Thomas Volpe SHU |
| Ja'Kerion Merritt CMU | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Matthew Morris MVILLE |