| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Crossover | ||
| P.J. Ogunsanya ARMY | DEC 6-3 | Corbyn Munson CMU |
| Matthew Williams ARMY | DEC 6-2 | Trenton Harder BLOOM |
| John Arceri BUFF | DEC 3-1 | Mason Breece CMU |
| Jacob Ealy PITT | PIN | Mark Metz ARMY |
| Connor Eck LHU | PIN | Michael Leandrou HOF |
| Paul Feite PSU | PIN | Marco Macrino BLOOM |
| Dashawn Farber LHU | PIN | Drew Witham Long Island University |
| Cory Crooks ORST | DEC 5-3 | Lane Stigall ORST |
| Robert Groves HARV | ||
| DEC 12-5 |
| Luca Pirozzolo SHU |
| Kaya Sement PENN | DEC 4-2 | Craig Cook |
| Cade Balestrini BLOOM | DEC 9-4 | Steven Storm LEH |
| Billy Griffin SHU | DEC 3-1 | Edward Scheck MVILLE |
| David Tufankjian SHU | FORFEIT | Matt Laurie SHU |
| Manzona Bryant LEH | DEC 4-1 | Jimmy Hoffman LEH |
| Jack Molloy SHU | PIN | Calum Price SHU |
| Round Robin 3 | ||
| Jacob Ealy PITT | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Robert Groves HARV |
| Nico Bogardus SHU | FORFEIT | Samuel Anglim Long Island University |
| Dashawn Farber LHU | DEC 6-1 | Cade Balestrini BLOOM |
| Vincenzo Miceli BLOOM | DEC 8-1 | Peter Haverick |
| Hayden Butterfield Gannon University | DEC 10-4 | Luke Hart VMI |
| Kaya Sement PENN | DEC 5-0 | Matt Laurie SHU |
| Connor Eck LHU | DEC 5-5 | Paul Feite PSU |
| Eric Shindel HOF | PIN | Joel Huck Gannon University |
| P.J. Ogunsanya ARMY | PIN | Lane Stigall ORST |
| John Arceri BUFF | DEC 7-4 | Craig Cook |
| Mark Metz ARMY | PIN | Billy Griffin SHU |
| Cory Crooks ORST | DEC 6-3 | Manzona Bryant LEH |
| Drew Witham Long Island University | DEC 8-7 | Steven Storm LEH |
| Michael Leandrou HOF | TF 16-0 | Calum Price SHU |
| Round Robin 2 | ||
| P.J. Ogunsanya ARMY | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Jimmy Hoffman LEH |
| Hayden Butterfield Gannon University | DEC 8-3 | Vincenzo Miceli BLOOM |
| Eric Shindel HOF | DEC 9-3 | Samuel Anglim Long Island University |
| Jacob Ealy PITT | PIN | Edward Scheck MVILLE |
| Joel Huck Gannon University | PIN | Nico Bogardus SHU |
| Connor Eck LHU | TF 19-4 | Jack Molloy SHU |
| Luke Hart VMI | DEC 4-0 | Peter Haverick |
| Matthew Williams ARMY | DEC 4-1 | Cade Balestrini BLOOM |
| Mason Breece CMU | DEC 4-4 | Kaya Sement PENN |
| Steven Storm LEH | DEC 3-2 | Trenton Harder BLOOM |
| Mark Metz ARMY | PIN | Luca Pirozzolo SHU |
| Corbyn Munson CMU | DEC 8-5 | Cory Crooks ORST |
| Craig Cook | TF 18-0 | David Tufankjian SHU |
| Michael Leandrou HOF | DEC 13-6 | Marco Macrino BLOOM |
| Round Robin 1 | ||
| Vincenzo Miceli BLOOM | DEC 8-4 | Luke Hart VMI |
| Nico Bogardus SHU | DEC 4-1 | Eric Shindel HOF |
| Paul Feite PSU | PIN | Jack Molloy SHU |
| Hayden Butterfield Gannon University | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Peter Haverick |
| Matthew Williams ARMY | DEC 3-2 | Dashawn Farber LHU |
| Mason Breece CMU | PIN | Matt Laurie SHU |
| Lane Stigall ORST | DEC 7-5 | Jimmy Hoffman LEH |
| Joel Huck Gannon University | PIN | Samuel Anglim Long Island University |
| Robert Groves HARV | PIN | Edward Scheck MVILLE |
| Corbyn Munson CMU | DEC 5-4 | Manzona Bryant LEH |
| John Arceri BUFF | TF 16-0 | David Tufankjian SHU |
| Marco Macrino BLOOM | TF 15-0 | Calum Price SHU |
| Luca Pirozzolo SHU | PIN | Billy Griffin SHU |
| Trenton Harder BLOOM | DEC 9-5 | Drew Witham Long Island University |