| Round of 16 |
| Cael Hughes OKST | PIN | Braden Haines Marian University (Ind.) |
| James Anderson Ouachita Baptist University | PIN | Eric Harmon Fontbonne University |
| Arojae Hart Indian Hills Community College | PIN | Jakob Smith Cloud County Community College |
| Jahleel Armstrong LIB | TF 16-1 | Jack Connell Triton College |
| Gavin Albers Rochester Community and Technical College | DEC 8-5 | Giovanni DeGeorge LIB |
| Anthony Schickel Triton College | TF 15-0 | Caydon Miller Labette Community College |
| Braden Tatum Lindenwood University | MAJ DEC 18-10 | Corban Zugelder Labette Community College |
| Landen Davis UCM | PIN | Daniel Vines Cloud County Community College |
| Trayce Eckman Bellarmine University | PIN | Nathan Berta Eureka College |
| Tyson Wilson Rochester Community and Technical College | PIN | Nathan Honhart University of the Cumberlands |
| Josh Sanders Bellarmine University | TF 18-2 | Perry Lake Quincy |
| Chase Arnestad LIB | TF 17-2 | Justin Johnson Wayland Baptist (Texas) |
| Luis Bazan NW | DEC 14-9 | Ostin Blanchard Bellarmine University |
| Ryder Clark Carl Albert State College | PIN | Trevor Wishne UCM |
| Daryl Mills Missouri Baptist University | PIN | Bernie Cox Eureka College |
| Zach Blankenship OKST | PIN | Evan Binder Maryville University |
