| Round of 16 |
| Carter Silva Quincy | PIN | Cody Martin McKendree University |
| Eric Streeter Labette Community College | PIN | Corey Hawkins Fontbonne University |
| Marc Le Gaspe University of the Cumberlands | PIN | Daniel Montijo Indian Hills Community College |
| Cohen Wiste Rochester Community and Technical College | PIN | Jesse Hinkle Indian Hills Community College |
| Drew Landau UCM | TF 16-1 | Jamarius Koshko Labette Community College |
| Ben Zeman Triton College | PIN | Collin Reif Lindenwood University |
| Trey Dillow Unattached | DEC 7-2 | Jaxon Keoltzow University of Central Oklahoma |
| Collin Arch NIU | PIN | Trenton Crowley Missouri Valley College |
| Yaveion Freeman Indian Hills Community College | DEC 4-2 | Joseph Insalaco Sierra College |
| Zach Wilson Marian University (Ind.) | PIN | Charles Hancock UCM |
| Garrett Lyons Unattached | DEC 6-5 | Ty Lehman University of the Cumberlands |
| Jake Romig Ouachita Baptist University | PIN | Humberto Pintor Quincy |
| Jewell Williams Bellarmine University | DEC 5-2 | Garrett Good LIB |
| Ryan Schepers McKendree University | TF 17-1 | Jake Meskauskas Joliet Junior College |
| Koye Grebel IOWA | TF 18-0 | Lucas Clement Quincy |
| Bishop Rush Missouri Valley College | DEC 7-2 | KingJames Perry Indian Hills Community College |
