| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Ian Bush WVU | PIN | Cooper Skelton OHIO |
| Alex Taylor Roanoke College | DEC 4-3 | Ryan Stein CHAT |
| Kingsley Menifee Morgan State University | TF 17-0 | Anthony Goelzer Limestone University |
| Wyatt Ferguson DAV | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Toby Schoffstall VMI |
| Vincenzo Corvetto Roanoke College | PIN | Jake Allred FM |
| Eric Washington Morgan State University | PIN | Chase Miller Unattached |
| Brian Finnerty Unattached | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Joe Burch Unattached |
| Evan Straub Tiffin University | DEC 3-2 | Kyle Grey Morgan State University |
| Dennis Robin WVU | PIN | Christos Avgeros Roanoke College |
| Zayne Lehman OHIO | DEC 4-1 | Hudson Stewart UVA |
| Caleb Hopkins CAMP | PIN | Gio Jackson Life University |
| Dylan Kohn WVU | PIN | Jaquez Bostic Limestone University |
| James Conway FM | DEC 17-14 | Hadyn Danals UVA |
| Trey Munoz ORST | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Conor Maslanek CAMP |
| Sam Fisher VT | TF 28-6 | Landon Lewis CHAT |
| Kyle Homet Life University | MAJ DEC 18-5 | River Carroll VMI |