| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round Robin 5 | ||
| PJ Casale RU | TF 18-2 | Kevin Taylor |
| Jackson Zimmerman PENN | FORFEIT | Mason Ellis Unattached |
| Round Robin 4 | ||
| PJ Casale RU | PIN | Jackson Zimmerman PENN |
| Noah Foster Nassau Community College | FORFEIT | Mason Ellis Unattached |
| Round Robin 3 | ||
| PJ Casale RU | PIN | Noah Foster Nassau Community College |
| Jackson Zimmerman PENN | DEC 6-3 | Kevin Taylor Unattached |
| Round Robin 2 | ||
| PJ Casale RU | FORFEIT | Mason Ellis Unattached |
| Kevin Taylor Unattached | PIN | Noah Foster Nassau Community College |
| Round Robin 1 | ||
| Mason Ellis Unattached | TF 19-3 | Kevin Taylor Unattached |
| Jackson Zimmerman PENN | TF 17-2 | Noah Foster Nassau Community College |