| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Paul Duggan CAMP | DEFAULT | Patrick Robinson PUR |
| James Bennett Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 8-6 | John Keck NAVY |
| Justin Melick EMU | PIN | Garrison Matthews CAMP |
| Craig Thomas OSU | MAJ DEC 14-6 | Anthony Ballinger California Baptist University |
| Bobby Nash MSU | DEC 5-3 | Tony Burge Notre Dame College |
| Tyler Tesny Lake Erie College | DEC 6-1 | Nathan Hartless EDIN |
| James Bennett Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 4-0 | Daniel Urban California Baptist University |
| Garrison Matthews CAMP | DEC 6-1 | Rocky Cantu Olivet College |
| Anthony Bill CMU | DEC 7-3 | Edward Nuttall Olivet College |
| Paul Duggan CAMP | PIN | Jacob Hosking Lake Erie College |
| Troy Reaghard PITT | DEC 7-4 | Troy Lamson MSU |