| Finals |
| Josh Demas OSU1st | DEC 2-1 | Brian Murphy MICH2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Markus Scheidel COLU3rd | DEC 2-1 | Spartak Chino OHIO4th |
| Andrew Romanchik OHIO5th | DEC 7-3 | Randy Languis OSU6th |
| Consi Semi |
| Randy Languis OSU | DEC 2-0 | Jake Salazar MICH |
| Andrew Romanchik OHIO | DEC 1-0 | Craig Eifert Finger Lakes Wrestling Club |
| Semifinal |
| Josh Demas OSU | DEC 3-1 | Spartak Chino OHIO |
| Brian Murphy MICH | DEC 3-1 | Markus Scheidel COLU |
| Consi 4 |
| Jake Salazar MICH | DEC 8-5 | Joe Cozart Lindsey Wilson College |
| Craig Eifert Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | DEC 3-1 | Jonaton Riveria Notre Dame College |
| Randy Languis OSU | DEC 2-1 | Roger Wildmo MSU |
| Andrew Romanchik OHIO | DEC 4-3 | Andrew Morse NIU |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Roger Wildmo MSU | PIN | Roman Perryman WVU |
| Andrew Morse NIU | DEC 5-2 | Dustin Schultz PUR |
| Craig Eifert Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Doug Welch PUR |
| Joe Cozart Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 3-2 | Jordan Cowell University of Findlay |
| Quarterfinal |
| Markus Scheidel COLU | DEC 7-3 | Jake Salazar MICH |
| Josh Demas OSU | DEC 4-2 | Andrew Romanchik OHIO |
| Brian Murphy MICH | DEC 7-0 | Randy Languis OSU |
| Spartak Chino OHIO | DEC 6-5 | Jonaton Riveria Notre Dame College |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Dustin Schultz PUR | DEC 5-4 | Joey White University of Findlay |
| Jordan Cowell University of Findlay | DEC 7-5 | Joseph Johnson MSU |
| Andrew Morse NIU | DEC 5-2 | Austin Culton NIU |
| Joe Cozart Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 11-6 | George Scheffel WVU |
| Roger Wildmo MSU | PIN | Isaac Morisette Lake Erie College |
| Craig Eifert Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Justin Melick EMU |
| Roman Perryman WVU | DEC 4-3 | Travis Curley MSU |
| Doug Welch PUR | DEC 5-3 | Matt Pasqualini MSU |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| George Scheffel WVU | DEC 8-1 | Robert Hughes MSU |
| Roman Perryman WVU | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Mike Clark St. Catharine College |
| Matt Pasqualini MSU | PIN | Zachary Heeter WVU |
| Austin Culton NIU | DEC 6-3 | Dalton Nicely University of Findlay |
| Roger Wildmo MSU | PIN | Andy Candiello KENT |
| Round of 16 |
| Jake Salazar MICH | DEC 3-2 | Travis Curley MSU |
| Spartak Chino OHIO | DEC 3-2 | Joey White University of Findlay |
| Josh Demas OSU | DEC 3-2 | Doug Welch PUR |
| Jonaton Riveria Notre Dame College | DEC 6-2 | Andrew Morse NIU |
| Markus Scheidel COLU | PIN | Isaac Morisette Lake Erie College |
| Brian Murphy MICH | DEC 4-0 | Jordan Cowell University of Findlay |
| Andrew Romanchik OHIO | DEC 5-0 | Craig Eifert Finger Lakes Wrestling Club |
| Randy Languis OSU | DEC 5-2 | Joe Cozart Lindsey Wilson College |
| Round of 32 |
| Joey White University of Findlay | DEC 3-2 | Andy Candiello KENT |
| Jordan Cowell University of Findlay | DEC 11-9 | Zachary Heeter WVU |
| Jonaton Riveria Notre Dame College | PIN | Mike Clark St. Catharine College |
| Joe Cozart Lindsey Wilson College | MAJ DEC 16-7 | Justin Melick EMU |
| Spartak Chino OHIO | DEC 10-5 | Roger Wildmo MSU |
| Brian Murphy MICH | DEC 9-1 | Matt Pasqualini MSU |
| Andrew Morse NIU | DEC 6-2 | Roman Perryman WVU |
| Travis Curley MSU | DEC 8-4 | Dalton Nicely University of Findlay |
| Doug Welch PUR | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Joseph Johnson |
