| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Scott Mattingly CMU | PIN | Blake Harvey UINDY |
| Mike Hillock MICH | DEC 11-4 | Billy Osborne CMU |
| Matt Smith Allegan HS | TF 21-5 | Chad Channel University of Findlay |
| David Ivashchenko CIT | DEC 12-6 | Johnny Henry UINDY |
| Ameer Al-Gharib MICH | PIN | Michael Hummer Unattached |
| Trey Weliver UINDY | DEC 2-1 | Greg Roberts Olivet College |
| Kyle Begg Tiffin University | PIN | Zack Boyer CIT |
| Pete Rendina MICH | DEC 5-1 | Nick Harris North Idaho College |