| Round of 32 |
| Vinny Punzone Notre Dame College | PIN | Kristopher McKinley Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Nick Simpson IND | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Jon Arenas Harper College |
| Connor Hughes Indiana Institute of Technology | TF 17-2 | Travis Fletcher Unattached |
| Dominic Olivieri ILL | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Andre Sanders Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Christian Yarbrough Indiana Institute of Technology | TF 22-6 | Ian Fitzpatrick Notre Dame College |
| Paul Beck UINDY | DEC 7-3 | Josh Hunter Ashland University |
| Edilberto Vinas KENT | DEC 12-5 | Brandon Preston Trine University |
| Dominic Price PUR | DEC 7-6 | Joey Morris Ashland University |
| Josh Kieffer UINDY | MAJ DEC 19-5 | Vinnie Pizzzuto EMU |
| Nick Harrison NIU | PIN | Dylan Hansen Harper College |
| Alfredo Gray KENT | DEC 6-3 | Luke Schroeder PUR |
| Brian Hauser Notre Dame College | TF 24-9 | Louis Dela Cruz Harper College |
| Cole Cochran Ohio Northern University | DEC 7-2 | Zach Hummel Harper College |
| Derek Elmore NIU | DEC 5-4 | Esteban Gonzales Olivet College |
| Matt Perez Notre Dame College | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Scott Spreng Ashland University |
| Kyle Visconti OSU | MAJ DEC 17-8 | Delian Schnieder Heidelberg University |
