| Round of 32 |
| Anthony Ayers Notre Dame College | PIN | Buddy Poyner EMU |
| Dan McNulty Ashland University | PIN | Victor Vettese University of Findlay |
| Kyle Bauer KENT | DEC 9-4 | Ryan Abrigo MICH |
| Travis Barroquillo Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 10-3 | Davion Caston Notre Dame College |
| Rudolph Pataro Ohio Northern University | PIN | Cameron Michel Heidelberg University |
| Connor Infelise Harper College | MAJ DEC 15-5 | Courtney Johnson Unattached |
| Joseph Her University of Wisconsin-Parkside | DEC 4-3 | Robert Buckhannon MSU |
| Brandon Fifield MSU | PIN | Mogos Tsegay EMU |
| Shane Troyer University of Findlay | DEC 4-2 | Andy Brown Grand Valley State |
| Jake Byers EMU | DEC 9-2 | Thorian Twyner NIU |
| Mike Carlone Cleveland State University | DEC 6-2 | Jimmy Schroader Unattached |
| Jesse Walker Notre Dame College | MAJ DEC 8-0 | John Coukos NW |
| Mike Gancer Olivet College | DEC 6-4 | Zebulon Hilyard MICH |
| Garret Garness OHIO | PIN | Steven Paster Tiffin University |
| Terry Turner MSU | DEC 8-3 | Michael Shaw EMU |
| Jordan Bosma Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 12-7 | Mike Manuche OSU |
