| Finals |
| Kenny Courts OSU1st | DEFAULT | Craig Thomas OSU2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Vince Pickett EDIN3rd | DEC 7-4 | Cody Rodgers OHIO4th |
| Charles Mason Notre Dame College5th | DEC 3-2 | Keith Johnson OHIO6th |
| Consi Semi |
| Cody Rodgers OHIO | DEC 3-0 | Keith Johnson OHIO |
| Vince Pickett EDIN | DEC 6-3 | Charles Mason Notre Dame College |
| Semifinal |
| Craig Thomas OSU | DEC 3-1 | Keith Johnson OHIO |
| Kenny Courts OSU | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Vince Pickett EDIN |
| Consi 4 |
| Charles Mason Notre Dame College | DEC 5-2 | Jeff Holm Olivet College |
| Cody Rodgers OHIO | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Zack Hernandez COLU |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Zack Hernandez COLU | PIN | Mike Auletta EDIN |
| Cody Rodgers OHIO | PIN | Miles Trealout MICH |
| Jeff Holm Olivet College | DEC 8-1 | Andrew Hissom PUR |
| Charles Mason Notre Dame College | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Austyn Hayes EDIN |
| Quarterfinal |
| Craig Thomas OSU | DEC 3-1 | Charles Mason Notre Dame College |
| Vince Pickett EDIN | DEC 6-1 | Zack Hernandez COLU |
| Kenny Courts OSU | MAJ DEC 17-5 | Cody Rodgers OHIO |
| Keith Johnson OHIO | DEC 7-6 | Jeff Holm Olivet College |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Mike Auletta EDIN | DEC 9-3 | Chris Choate Unattached |
| Andrew Hissom PUR | DEC 5-4 | Thomas Buckman Lindsey Wilson College |
| Austyn Hayes EDIN | DEC 10-5 | Austin Severn CMU |
| Miles Trealout MICH | DEC 8-6 | Conor Murray Notre Dame College |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Chris Choate Unattached | DEC 4-1 | David Stevens Manchester University |
| Thomas Buckman Lindsey Wilson College | MAJ DEC 16-2 | Toby Kirts Manchester University |
| Miles Trealout MICH | DEC 10-3 | David Sparling MICH |
| Mike Auletta EDIN | PIN | Taylor DeLong Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Austyn Hayes EDIN | DEC 4-3 | Michael Baker Notre Dame College |
| Conor Murray Notre Dame College | PIN | Josh Cook Kennedy King College |
| Andrew Hissom PUR | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Zach Housholder University of Findlay |
| Austin Severn CMU | DEC 6-5 | Jacob Berkowitz NW |
| Round of 16 |
| Vince Pickett EDIN | PIN | Jacob Berkowitz NW |
| Cody Rodgers OHIO | DEC 7-4 | Thomas Buckman Lindsey Wilson College |
| Keith Johnson OHIO | DEC 7-3 | Miles Trealout MICH |
| Kenny Courts OSU | TF 17-2 | Zach Housholder University of Findlay |
| Zack Hernandez COLU | DEC 6-3 | Michael Baker Notre Dame College |
| Craig Thomas OSU | DEC 8-3 | Chris Choate Unattached |
| Jeff Holm Olivet College | DEC 8-1 | Conor Murray Notre Dame College |
| Charles Mason Notre Dame College | MAJ DEC 16-6 | Taylor DeLong Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Round of 32 |
| Kenny Courts OSU | TF 21-5 | Mike Auletta EDIN |
| Vince Pickett EDIN | TF 17-0 | David Sparling MICH |
| Craig Thomas OSU | TF 20-5 | Toby Kirts Manchester University |
| Keith Johnson OHIO | DEC 3-2 | Austin Severn CMU |
| Zack Hernandez COLU | PIN | Josh Cook Kennedy King College |
| Jeff Holm Olivet College | DEC 3-1 | Austyn Hayes EDIN |
| Charles Mason Notre Dame College | DEC 9-5 | Andrew Hissom PUR |
| Cody Rodgers OHIO | PIN | David Stevens Manchester University |
