| Round of 32 |
| Cody Pae PUR | PIN | Landon Nave Calumet College of St. Joseph |
| Matt Leshinger COLU | DEC 4-1 | Nick Bloch Lake Erie College |
| Paxton Edgar Lindenwood-Belleville | PIN | Josh Juarez Manchester University |
| Ryan Murdock COLU | DEC 3-1 | Coby Fehr Lake Erie College |
| Dylan Kager Lake Erie College | PIN | Isiah Deguzman Notre Dame College |
| John Weldon Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 6-0 | Tyler Kuch Olivet College |
| Christian Olanowski MSU | DEC 5-3 | Adam Nichols CMU |
| Kaelan Richards MSU | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Austin Kelley Olivet College |
| Keaton Thomas Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 7-5 | Kyle Sether Unattached |
| Jared VanVleet University of Findlay | DEC 10-9 | Brandon Miller Notre Dame College |
| James Jenkins Notre Dame College | MAJ DEC 15-5 | Logan Hatfield Lindsey Wilson College |
| Andrew Bannister Notre Dame College | TF 16-1 | Recco Samuel EDIN |
| Wardell Morgan Lindenwood-Belleville | PIN | Brendan Quigley OHIO |
| Sal Annoreno NIU | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Billy Waldeck OHIO |
| Noah Forrider OHIO | DEC 6-5 | Cameron Kennedy MICH |
