| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Christian Price Ashland University | TF 17-2 | Nicholas Guerra Olivet College |
| Gabe Koontz IND | TF 17-1 | Jacob Lay Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Tyler Grimsley Olivet College | PIN | Kamyab Kamali University of Notre Dame |
| Travis Lucius University of Notre Dame | DEC 12-5 | Tristan Sanders Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Jeremy Scott OSU | DEC 7-2 | Austin Vannatter Davenport University |
| David Kasper EMU | DEC 4-1 | Stephen Myers Lindsey Wilson College |