| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| John Engel LEH1st | PIN 9:00 | Jesse Arends UNI2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Andrew Hesser OKST | DEC | Stanley Ball |
| Jesse Arends UNI | DEC | Andrew Hesser OKST |
| Andrew Hesser OKST | PIN 1:59 | S.D. Daniels Tufts |
| S.D. Daniels Tufts | FORFEIT | C.N. Kasden BRWN |
| Semifinal | ||
| John Engel LEH | DEC | Stanley Ball MSU |
| Jesse Arends UNI | PIN 4:05 | S.D. Daniels Tufts |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| John Engel LEH | DEC | Andrew Hesser OKST |
| Stanley Ball MSU | PIN 13:54 | Sumner Forward CUSE |
| S.D. Daniels Tufts | PIN 5:37 | Daniel Dicenzo Rhode Island |
| Jesse Arends UNI | PIN 1:45 | C.N. Kasden BRWN |