| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| LeRoy McGuirk OKST1st | DEC | John Richardson Kansas State2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Bob Miller NW | DEC | |
| D.E. Coe Springfield College |
| Bob Miller NW | DEC | Max Silverstein NAVY |
| John Richardson Kansas State | DEC | Bob Miller NW |
| Orville Orr UNI | DEC | Elmer Carpenter CUSE |
| Orville Orr UNI | FORFEIT | Bob Miller NW |
| Semifinal | ||
| LeRoy McGuirk OKST | DEC | Max Silverstein NAVY |
| John Richardson Kansas State | DEC | Elmer Carpenter CUSE |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| LeRoy McGuirk OKST | DEC | D.E. Coe Springfield College |
| John Richardson Kansas State | DEC | Orville Orr UNI |
| Elmer Carpenter CUSE | DEC | James Fawcett RU |
| Max Silverstein NAVY | PIN 3:14 | Ned Brody BRWN |
| Round of 16 | ||
| LeRoy McGuirk OKST | DEC | Bob Miller NW |
| D.E. Coe Springfield College | DEC | Pett Wheaton |
| Elmer Carpenter CUSE | DEC | W.A. Robertson HARV |
| James Fawcett RU | PIN 1:35 | L.J. Vassolotti MIT |