| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Rex Peery OKST1st | PIN 5:52 | George Ledbetter ILL2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Rowland Thomas Washington & Lee | ||
| PIN 3:41 |
| Ken Beaulieu BRWN |
| Willard Duffy IND | PIN 3:50 | Rowland Thomas Washington & Lee |
| Willard Duffy IND | PIN 5:09 | George Ledbetter ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| Rex Peery OKST | DEC | Willard Duffy IND |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Willard Duffy IND | PIN 7:43 | James Steiner UNI |
| George Ledbetter ILL | DEC | Leonard Fauver OSU |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Rowland Thomas Washington & Lee | PIN 5:57 | Paul Cullather East Stroudsburg University |
| Leonard Fauver OSU | PIN 9:00 | Ray Pagan Tufts |
| James Steiner UNI | DEC | Joe Parkey Southwestern Oklahoma |
| George Ledbetter ILL | DEC | Rudy Ashman LEH |