| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Porter Robertson OKLA1st | DEC | Paul Green Northeastern State2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Joe Johnston WVU | — | |
| Glenn King University of Central Oklahoma |
| Earl Kielhorn IOWA | DEFAULT | Porter Robertson OKLA |
| Earl Kielhorn IOWA | DEFAULT | Joe Johnston WVU |
| Glenn King University of Central Oklahoma | FORFEIT | Olden Gillum IND |
| Semifinal | ||
| Howard Johnston PSU | PIN 8:14 | Joe Johnston WVU |
| Paul Green Northeastern State | PIN 5:08 | Herman Bassman Ursinus College |
| Porter Robertson OKLA | DEC | Art Loux LEH |
| Earl Kielhorn IOWA | DEC | Bill Currence VMI |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Art Loux LEH | PIN 2:15 | Charles Fort DAV |
| Paul Green Northeastern State | PIN 2:41 | Herman Miller TEMPLE |
| Bill Currence VMI | DEC | Kodis Springfield College |
| Herman Bassman Ursinus College | DEC | Charles Andrews ILL |
| Joe Johnston WVU | DEC | Henry Raab FM |
| Porter Robertson OKLA | DEFAULT | Dormer Browning OKST |
| Earl Kielhorn IOWA | DEC | Claude Young Kansas State |
| Howard Johnston PSU | FORFEIT | Olden Gillum IND |
| Pigtail | ||
| Dormer Browning OKST | DEC | Elliott Harris Lafayette |
| Howard Johnston PSU | DEC | Glenn King University of Central Oklahoma |
| Olden Gillum IND | DEC | Clayton Bates St. Lawrence |
| Porter Robertson OKLA | DEC | George Triede PRIN |