| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Ralph Silverstein ILL1st | DEC | Orville Nickerson Southwestern Oklahoma2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Ray Yoder PSU | ||
| DEC |
| Ed Paquette St. Lawrence |
| Lloyd Ricks OKST | DEC | Orville Nickerson Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Lloyd Ricks OKST | DEFAULT | Ray Yoder PSU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Ralph Silverstein ILL | DEC | Lloyd Ricks OKST |
| Orville Nickerson Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Ed King COLU |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ralph Silverstein ILL | PIN 4:22 | Ed Paquette St. Lawrence |
| Orville Nickerson Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | John Burgess VMI |
| Lloyd Ricks OKST | DEC | Harvey Serfass Gettysburg College |
| Round of 16 | ||
| John Burgess VMI | PIN 9:45 | Vern Heiser OSU |
| Ed Paquette St. Lawrence | PIN 4:16 | Stan Goodrich LEH |
| Ralph Silverstein ILL | PIN 3:34 | Ray Yoder PSU |
| Ed King COLU | DEC | John Gruszecki KENT |
| Lloyd Ricks OKST | DEC | Ray Bunch Cornell College |
| Orville Nickerson Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Dean Swift Kansas State |
| Harvey Serfass Gettysburg College | DEC | Leo Millsaps Maryville University |