| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consolation | ||
| Chris Traicoff IND | — | Howard Peters CUSE |
| Howard Peters CUSE | FORFEIT | Don Nichols MICH |
| Semifinal | ||
| John Harkness HARV | DEC | |
| Wesley Leverich ILL |
| Marshall Word OKLA | DEC | Edward Valorz University of Chicago |
| Swede Olsen Southwestern Oklahoma | DEFAULT | Don Nichols MICH |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Swede Olsen Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Howard Peters CUSE |
| Chris Traicoff IND | DEC | Ernest Bortz PSU |
| John Harkness HARV | DEC | James Taylor Cornell College |
| Wesley Leverich ILL | DEC | Graze CCNY |
| Edward Valorz University of Chicago | DEC | Smith San Jose State |