| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Henry Wittenberg CCNY1st | DEC | S.M. Slezak MSU2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Don Nichols MICH | DEC | Bill Lyman Cornell College |
| Bob Williams OKST | DEC | S.M. Slezak MSU |
| Bob Williams OKST | DEFAULT | Don Nichols MICH |
| Bob Williams OKST | DEC | D.G. Grant Springfield College |
| Henry Wittenberg CCNY | DEC | Don Nichols MICH |
| Semifinal | ||
| Bill Lyman Cornell College | PIN 3:49 | Lloyd Black TEMPLE |
| S.M. Slezak MSU | DEC | Ben Schrader LEH |
| Henry Wittenberg CCNY | DEC | Bob Williams OKST |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Henry Wittenberg CCNY | PIN 6:57 | D.G. Grant Springfield College |
| Bill Lyman Cornell College | PIN 2:48 | Ernest Bortz PSU |
| S.M. Slezak MSU | DEC | Edward Valorz University of Chicago |
| Bob Williams OKST | DEC | John Hauer YALE |
| Lloyd Black TEMPLE | DEC | J.M. Vanderpool MIT |