| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Gene Grenard Colorado State University1st | PIN 7:47 | Chauncey McDaniel IND2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Clay Albright OKST | ||
| PIN 9:30 |
| Bob Rhinehart TEMPLE |
| Clay Albright OKST | DEC | Chauncey McDaniel IND |
| Bob Rhinehart TEMPLE | DEFAULT | Ken Berry ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| Gene Grenard Colorado State University | DEC | Clay Albright OKST |
| Chauncey McDaniel IND | DEC | Ben Schrader LEH |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Clay Albright OKST | DEC | Joe Demasi RU |
| Chauncey McDaniel IND | DEC | Richard Moore Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Gene Grenard Colorado State University | DEC | Ken Berry ILL |
| Round of 16 | ||
| William Perry Lafayette | PIN 7:10 | Sam Linn ISU |
| Gene Grenard Colorado State University | PIN 4:44 | Bob Rhinehart TEMPLE |
| Chauncey McDaniel IND | DEC | Keith Collins Kansas State |
| Ken Berry ILL | DEC | Philip Lewandowski OHIO |
| Richard Moore Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Quentin Joy Cornell College |
| Clay Albright OKST | DEC | James Galles MICH |
| Joe Demasi RU | DEC | Norm Willey PUR |