| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Ray Stone ISU | — | John Cooper St. Lawrence |
| Loy Julius | ||
| — |
| Robert McArdle WVU |
| Milton Conzett University of Dubuque | — | Jack Grifo Lafayette |
| Dillard Talbutt OKST | — | James Laggan PENN |
| Delbert Jensen UNI | — | Cliff Perrizo MINN |
| John McGrath VMI | — | Mel Baldwin WYO |
| Burl Jennings MSU | DEC 5-2 | Frank Bailey LEH |
| Mike Slepecky KENT | DEC 11-9 | Robert Antonacci IND |