| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Lester Davidson UNCO | PIN 5:53 | Wendell Harris Wheaton |
| Gale Mikles MSU | PIN 5:30 | Virgil Counsell |
| Don Mullison Colorado State University | DEC 10-4 | Delbert Bush ISU |
| Bill Courtright MICH | DEC 9-3 | Emil Tomick APP |
| Kenneth Marlin ILL | DEC 9-4 | Jack St. Clair OKST |
| Ledger Stecker OKLA | DEC 7-3 | Kent Lange Cornell College |
| James Wilkinson IND | DEC 5-1 | Grant Dixon PSU |