| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Gene Lybbert UNI1st | DEC 8-1 | Donald Reece |
| Medal Round | ||
| Dick Lemyre PSU3rd | DEC 3-2 | George Lewis Waynesburg University4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| George Lewis Waynesburg University | DEC 8-3 | Don Meeker OKST |
| Dick Lemyre PSU | DEC 7-6 | Phil Duggan IOWA |
| Semifinal | ||
| Gene Lybbert UNI | DEC 11-8 | Dick Lemyre PSU |
| Donald Reece OKLA | DEC 5-4 | George Lewis Waynesburg University |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Phil Duggan IOWA | DEC 3-0 | Bob Datteri Colorado State University |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Donald Reece OKLA | DEC 7-2 | Bob Datteri Colorado State University |
| Gene Lybbert UNI | DEC 12-6 | Louis Oscarson ISU |
| Dick Lemyre PSU | DEC 8-6 | Don Meeker OKST |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Norvard Nalan MICH | PIN 1:11 | Robert Speck BYU |
| Don Meeker OKST | PIN 1:25 | Lester Kroeger UNCO |
| Gene Lybbert UNI | DEC 4-0 | Phil Duggan IOWA |
| Dick Lemyre PSU | DEC 8-2 | Merele Dunn ILL |
| Bob Datteri Colorado State University | DEC 7-3 | Richard Leffler Toledo |